“武备真传卷一许青云重辑”（见图1）、“武备真传卷二许青云重辑”。这两

"Xu Qingyun Wubei true mass weight Series Volume" (see FIG. 1), "the true mass Wubei Series Volume Xu Qingyun weight." All the elements contained in two volumes as "Ocean's supplement line of work bunt." The so-called heavy series, that "supplement Lohan line of work bunt" had been compiled in the past, it proved there is spread before Qianlong twenty-seven years. The so-called supplements, indicating that the contents of the "Ocean bunt line of work" than "Ocean's supplement line of work bunt" appears much earlier. Anyway, it can be concluded Rohan line of work is not bunt boxing spectrum Qianlong asked Xu Qingyun, or anyone else book, not only for our predecessors of Anonymous.

"Wu bev true biography volume a little Qingyun resusal" (see figure 1), "Wu bev true biography two Xu Qingyun re-series." The contents of these two volumes are "supplemented Rohan's short-term work". The so-called reissue, the description of "adding Rohan's short-term work" in the past has been recorded, proving that Qianlong 27 years ago it existed in circulation. The so-called addition, indicating that the content of "Rohan's short work" appears earlier than "adding Rohan's short play". In any case, it can be concluded that Luo Han's short-handed boxing score is not Qianlong years asked By Xu Qingyun or someone else, can only be the predecessor of the nameless work.

"Martial arts true biography Volume I Xu Qingyun re collection" (see Figure 1), "martial arts true biography Volume II Xu Qingyun re collection". The contents of these two volumes are "supplementary arhat Xinggong short fighting". The so-called reduplication shows that "supplementary luohanxinggong short fight" has been edited and recorded before, which proves that it existed and spread 27 years ago in Qianlong. The so-called supplement shows that the content of "luohanxinggong short fight" appeared earlier than "supplement luohanxinggong short fight". In any case, it can be concluded that the boxing Manual of Luohan Xinggong short fight was not written by Xu Qingyun or anyone else asked in Qianlong's year, but only by an anonymous predecessor.